The British Science Festival

Bringing the latest in science discovery to a city near you

18/05/2013

Show me content for... +

Show me content for...
Events
Resources
Volunteers
Teachers
Professional development
Families & teenagers (aged 12+)
Families (children aged 12 & under)

Donate

register

Register with us and you can....

  • Sign up to our free e-communications
  • Become a member of the Association
  • Create your own web account, & post comments
  • Be part of British Science Festival
  • Save your favourite items

Register

Keep up to date with the latest news from the British Science Assocation. Sign up to our RSS feeds and take us with you when you are on the move.

You are here

Famous faces in Aberdeen

Maggie Aderin-Pocock

Famous faces in Aberdeen

Brian Cox

Famous faces in Aberdeen

Bill Bryson

Famous faces in Aberdeen

John Krebs

Famous faces in Aberdeen

Paul Nurse

Famous faces in Aberdeen

Richard Wiseman

Famous faces in Aberdeen

Susan Greenfield

Polygraph on Trial—should lie detector evidence be admissible in Legal Proceedings in England and Wales?

State: 
Approved
Contact Details
I am the event manager: 
I am the event manager
Event Manager Info
1. Event Manager Organisation: 
Northumbria University
2. Event Manager First Name: 
Alexandra
3. Event Manager Surname: 
Robson
9. Event Manager Email address: 
Your event
10. Which of the following areas of science does you event best fit into?: 
Psychology
Event type and format
11. Do you have a preferred day for your event to take place on?: 
Saturday 7 September 2013
17. Length: 
2 hour
18. What will the format of your event be?: 
Demo followed by talk/lecture
19. Please give any details about the format of your event you feel are relevant.: 
Demonstration of polygraph examination by a polygraph examiner; consideration of the reliability of polygraph evidence by Professor Don Grubin, Professor of Forensic Psychiatry, Newcastle University; consideration of the legal rules that currently prevent the admissibility of polygraph evidence in England and Wales by Dr Michael Stockdale, Director of the Centre for Evidence and Criminal Justice Studies, Faculty of Business and Law, Northumbria University
20. Location/venue: 
City Campus East University of Northumbria/one of the lecture theatres in City Campus East 1
22. Audience Level: 
All adults
Event details
12. Event title: 
Polygraph on Trial—should lie detector evidence be admissible in Legal Proceedings in England and Wales?
13. Description of the core message of your event and key topics to be covered (c.100 words): 
From a scientific perspective, we will explore the extent to which polygraph evidence is capable of providing a reliable and relevant source of forensic evidence From the legal point of view, our concern is with the rules of the law of evidence which are commonly believed to limit the admissibility of polygraph evidence in criminal and civil proceedings in England and Wales A key issue is whether polygraph evidence is sufficiently reliable to justify its admission in evidence alongside other forms of forensic evidence such as fingerprints, footwear impression, and eye witness testimony. Where polygraph evidence has been excluded, this has been on a case by case base, and based on considerations other than reliability
16. How does your event relate to this year's theme of 'Making waves'?: 
The area is controversial because currently the domestic courts merely assume that polygraph evidence is inadmissible with little or no analysis, whereas other forms of forensic evidence have been admitted with relatively little scrutiny. The use of polygraph testing has now been sanctioned by Parliament in the context of monitoring sex offenders by the probation service following release from prison.
Press interest
23. Do you consider that the event will attract press interest?: 
Yes
24. If yes, please summarise up to 4 key points you think will be of press interest: 
The use of polygraphy in sex offender supervision has attracted wide media interest, including the broadsheets, tabloids, radio, and television. - Whether polygraph evidence should be received by courts - The accuracy and reliability of polygraph testing - The use of polygraph evidence re sex offender release - Whether the polygraph can be ‘beat’
25. Do you have any other comments you would like to make or information you would like to include?: 
IMPORTANT - The topic will not be unsuitable for a family audience—there may be some reference to sex offenders but only re the risk of re-offending in the context of release with no specific details of their crimes—though the legal content might not be of interest to young children.

Twitter latest